An analysis of statewide election recounts, 2000-2025
Read the full report below, or download a PDF version here.
Executive summary
Conducting election recounts to ensure fair and accurate democratic outcomes is a critical component of effective election administration. Trust in elections requires trust in a jurisdiction’s recount process. It is an ongoing learning experience for election administrators to conduct efficient and reputable recounts, as well as to determine when victory margins and data from post-election audits should trigger a recount.
In this report, we quantify various aspects of statewide recounts in the United States between 2000 and 2025, including how often they occur, how often they change outcomes, and how much vote totals change. We also track which states have made recent changes to their recount laws. We use this analysis to make recommendations for policymakers on recount laws. Our main findings are:
- Full statewide recounts are rare: Out of the 7,437 statewide general elections between 2000 and 2025, there were 37 complete statewide recounts. In other words, there was one full recount for every 201 statewide elections. Partial recounts are more common: Recounts often stop before they’re completed, usually when the losing candidate concedes.
- Outcome reversals are even rarer: Recounts resulted in only three reversals in this time period. All three reversals occurred when the initial margin was less than 0.06% of all votes cast for the top two candidates. The last statewide recount reversal was the 2008 U.S. Senate race in Minnesota.
- Recounts tend to shift only a small number of votes: Statewide recounts resulted in an average margin shift of 536 votes between the frontrunners, representing 0.03% of the vote. Recounts more often expand the winner’s lead than shrink it.
- Several states have updated their recount procedures in recent years. These changes were typically prompted by recent close races in those states.
- States should require automatic recounts in close races: When the margin is very close (within 0.1%), a recount should occur automatically, without a candidate or voters having to petition for one. 27 states and Washington, DC conduct recounts automatically when an election is very close, but seven of those only do so in the event of an exact tie.
- A threshold for campaign-requested recounts can prevent frivolous recounts: Most states that allow campaign-requested recounts have no upper limit on when these recounts may be requested. Limiting campaign-requested recounts to races with a close margin (1% or less) would prevent frivolous recounts.
- Recount laws should go hand-in-hand with rigorous post-election audit procedures: Post-election audits should be tailored to the margins in each race, and the number of audited ballots should increase in relation to the percentage of discrepancies found as the audit progresses.
Recounts in statewide elections, 2000-2025
Between 2000 and 2025, there were 7,437 statewide elections, including for president, U.S. senator, governor, secretary of state, ballot measures, and other offices.
Out of the 7,437 elections, there were a total of 37 completed recounts: 23 automatic and 14 requested, meaning there were fewer than two recounts per year.
Election recounts by type
Ballot measures and judicial office elections had the most recounts in this time period (eight and nine), but there are also more total elections in those categories. When viewed as a percentage of total elections, the most high-profile races – for president, senator, and governor – are the most likely to go to a recount.
Share of elections ending with a recount, by election type
Elections with outcome reversals
Only three out of the 37 statewide recounts – less than 10% – resulted in changed outcomes. These elections all had exceptionally close margins in the initial count.
The Washington gubernatorial election in 2004 was initially declared for Republican Dino Rossi, who was ahead by 261 votes statewide, or just 0.01%. After the recount, Democrat Christine Gregoire won by 129 votes out of 2,746,593 votes cast, or 0.005%. The recount shifted the margin by 390 votes, a change of 0.01 percentage points.
Vermont’s state auditor race in 2006 initially appeared to re-elect Republican incumbent Randy Brock by a margin of 137 votes, a lead of 0.06%. After the recount, Democratic challenger Thomas Salmon won the election by a margin of 102 votes, or 0.05%. The recount changed the margin in Salmon’s favor by 239 votes, or 0.11 percentage points. Most of the change occurred in localities that had inaccurately recorded ballot counts by hand on election night.
Minnesota’s U.S. Senate election in 2008 also included a high-profile recount that reversed the original outcome. Minnesota law called for automatic recounts for margins less than 0.5%. Democratic challenger Al Franken entered the state-mandated recount trailing by only 215 votes, or 0.01%, against Republican incumbent Norm Coleman. After a months-long legal process that included questions of voter intent in filling out paper ballots, Franken finished with 225 more votes than Coleman. The recount delivered a 440-vote swing to Franken, a change of 0.02 percentage points between the two candidates.
Close margins are needed for reversals to be plausible
In all three reversals, the initial margin between the top two candidates was 0.06% or less. The chart below plots the initial margin for each completed recount from 2000 to 2025; the three red bars represent the three outcome reversals, and the dotted line represents FairVote’s recommended 0.1% threshold to trigger an automatic recount.
Margin for reversed and upheld recounts
Most recounts fell outside of the margin where an outcome reversal is plausible. While all three reversals had an initial margin less than 0.06%, the remaining 34 recounts had a median margin of 0.18%, with most falling outside of FairVote’s recommended 0.1% automatic recount threshold.
Partial recounts tend not to change the initial outcome
In some cases, election administrators have performed partial recounts, and these recounts are even less likely to reverse the outcome than statewide recounts. Partial recounts are not included in our totals, but are addressed in this section.
Partial recounts are sometimes ordered in certain counties only, or are sometimes begun as statewide recounts but cut short when the losing candidate concedes. Examples of partial recounts include the 1988 U.S. Senate race in Florida, the 1998 attorney general race in New York, the 1998 U.S. Senate race in Nevada, the 2002 gubernatorial race in Alabama, the 2020 presidential race in Arizona, and the 2024 U.S. Senate race in Pennsylvania.
Partial statewide recounts also occurred in Ohio during the 2004 presidential race, and in a U.S. Senate race in Indiana in 2006. These recounts were both requested by petitioners seeking to draw attention to problems in how ballots were counted, not to reverse outcomes.
Recounts lead to negligible vote gains for both sides
Recounts typically lead to a slightly higher vote total overall. Much of this hinges on determinations of voter intent, often on ballots that were unreadable by tabulation machines.
Among the 37 statewide recounts since 2000, the vote totals increased for 76% of candidates and ballot measure positions. In two-thirds (65%) of recounts, the number of votes increased for both sides. On average, winning candidates increased their vote totals by 0.08 percentage points, and runners-up increased their vote totals by 0.07 percentage points. This almost-negligible change in votes reinforces the argument that extremely close margins are a necessary condition for a recount to possibly overturn an outcome.
Overview of existing state recount laws
Twenty-seven states and the District of Columbia have laws in place that require automatic recounts for state and federal elections when certain conditions are met. The requirements to trigger an automatic recount vary by state.
Criteria for automatic recounts
Twenty-three states do not have automatic recount laws, but 22 of those have laws permitting a request for a recount. Only Mississippi does not have any recount provisions in place in the event of a close race.
Numerous states empower voters and political parties to request recounts. Some states only allow candidates to petition if the results are within a particular margin, while other states charge candidates a fee to petition. The fees are typically returned to the petitioner if the recount changes the outcome of the election in the petitioner’s favor.
Since 2020, numerous states have made changes to their recount laws. In most cases, lawmakers passed the new laws in response to close elections in the preceding years. Notable changes since 2020 include:
- Arizona increased its threshold for an automatic state-funded recount in 2022, from races within a 0.1% margin to races within a 0.5% margin. Later that year, Arizona conducted automatic recounts in two statewide races, neither of which would have occurred automatically had lawmakers not raised the threshold. Neither recount led to a meaningful change in votes or an outcome reversal.
- Michigan added new provisions in 2024 that establish automatic recounts when races are within a 0.1% margin, prohibit candidate-requested recounts based solely on allegations of fraud, and place a larger cost burden on the petitioner in races with very large margins.
- Iowa established an upper bound for when a candidate can request a recount – a 0.15% margin. The bill’s legislative champion, Rep. Austin Harris, praised the effort for bringing “uniformity, consistency, and most importantly, trust to the system.”
- Maine passed an automatic recount law for tied elections in response to a tied state legislative race in 2024. While a recount was ultimately requested and conducted in that tied race, the lack of an automatic recount provision cost extra time and money before the recount could be initiated.
- Georgia passed a law mandating automatic hand recounts for state-level races within a 0.5% margin. The high margin, paired with a mandate to count by hand, could add significant time and expenses for Georgia election officials in contests that are not close enough for an outcome reversal to be plausible.
Allowing campaign-funded recounts with no threshold can lead to frivolous recounts
There have been a large number of campaign-funded recounts in recent years, many of which do not meet our criteria for full statewide recounts and are not included in our analysis. However, this section will briefly consider the recent trend of recounts that are funded by campaigns or private organizations, and where the margins fall outside of the range where they could be considered consequential.
On the state level, there have been several noteworthy campaign-funded recounts for which an outcome reversal was not plausible. These recounts produced negligible results. In Nevada’s 2022 Republican gubernatorial primary, Joey Gilbert’s campaign paid $190,000 to recount votes in all 17 of the state’s counties after the original tally showed he trailed his opponent Joe Lombardo by 11 percentage points. Tina Peters, a Republican candidate for secretary of state in Colorado, paid $256,000 for a statewide recount even though she trailed by 14 percentage points. This landed her only 13 additional votes. In Kansas, anti-abortion activists spent $120,000 for a recount of the highly contested No State Constitutional Right to Abortion ballot measure that lost 59-41%.
Partial recounts in the 2020 presidential election occurred in several states where the margins of victory were outside the range where an outcome reversal was plausible. In 2020, five pro-Donald Trump organizations gave $5.6 million to fund a recount in Maricopa County, the most populous county in Arizona. The original tally showed Joe Biden winning Arizona by more than 10,400 votes, or 0.3%, which is larger than the margin that would have triggered an automatic recount under the law at the time. The recount yielded 99 additional votes for Biden and 261 fewer votes for Trump. Similarly, in Wisconsin, the Trump campaign paid approximately $3 million to fund a partial recount in Milwaukee County and Dane County after Biden held a 22,500 vote lead (or 0.6%) over Trump. This recount also resulted in a net vote gain for Biden.
Conducting these recounts when there were not close victory margins in either state not only produced arbitrary vote gains, but also undermined voter faith in election integrity. The lack of confidence in the country’s ability to conduct an honest election puts the overall democratic process into jeopardy. While recounts are crucial in very close races, frivolous recounts in races that are not close do more harm than good. Post-election audits, now in place in every state, do a better job of validating election results than frivolous recounts.
North Carolina’s 2024 State Supreme Court race is an example of a useful and non-frivolous recount. We address it here to emphasize what typically can and cannot be accomplished by recounts. The candidates, Jefferson Griffin and Allison Riggs, were separated by 734 votes out of 2.8 million – a 0.013% margin. After the trailing candidate requested a recount, the margin remained at 0.013%, with both candidates having earned 110 fewer votes in the recount. This is typical, as we rarely see large changes from recounting the same set of ballots. Notably, the race then moved to a court battle over whether 60,000 overseas ballots should be disqualified due to voter eligibility. Beyond recounts, very close elections sometimes go to court over questions of eligibility; the qualification of large groups of ballots can have a much larger impact than a recount.
Counting procedures for recounts
Just as recounts can be triggered differently in different states, recounts are often conducted differently due to different election equipment and recount requirements. Moreover, the circumstances leading to a recount can affect what kind of recount is done. In the 2004 U.S. Senate race in Alaska, for example, all ballots were re-scanned, and there was a manual hand count of a sample of ballots in order to evaluate concerns that tabulation machines were not tallying all ballots accurately.
In Minnesota’s 2008 U.S. Senate race, a statewide manual hand count was conducted because Minnesota law seeks to verify voter intent. Full manual hand recounts decided the 2006 state auditor race in Vermont, the 2004 constitutional amendment referendum in Alabama, and the 2004 gubernatorial race in Washington. All recounts prior to the introduction of voting machines involved manual hand counting, while the 2000 State Education Board election in Colorado was an early example of an automatic machine recount.
Margin shifts in recounts tend to reflect the process by which the ballots were recounted, although the differences are not dramatic. Manual hand recounts are more costly and time-intensive than machine counts, and require careful procedures to minimize human error. Such manual recounts have tended to result in larger margin swings, presumably because humans evaluated voter intent differently (and ideally more accurately) than the machines in the original count.
Implications for policymakers
Our findings indicate that the overwhelming majority of elections have outcomes that are not realistically disputable, absent genuine indications of systematic fraud or error. In the relatively few statewide races with recounts in the last 25 years, the original outcome was rarely overturned, and initial victory margins only changed slightly. Yet recounts should be conducted in exceptionally close races even if costly to taxpayers – and procedures should be in place to identify fraud or error.
Given data on margin shifts in statewide recounts with modern voting machines, we recommend a 0.1% initial margin as a threshold for automatic recounts. Our research indicates that only elections within that margin are close enough that a recount could plausibly alter the outcome, although reversals are rare even within that margin.
The 23 states without any automatic recount provisions should establish them. At the same time, the states that conduct automatic recounts based on higher thresholds could safely lower their thresholds while still ensuring accurate election outcomes. This would reduce the number of inconsequential recounts and save taxpayer money.
Automatic recounts within the 0.1% margin should be state-funded, because it is a key function of state governments to ensure accurate election outcomes. Requested recounts outside of that margin are not considered plausible and should be funded by the petitioner to avoid extra taxpayer burden.
Additionally, we recommend that recount statutes include an upper margin limit for campaign-requested recounts. We recommend allowing candidate-requested recounts in races with a margin of up to 1%, and ensuring that those requested recounts are funded by the individual or entity that requests them. In races with larger margins of victory, there is no realistic chance that a recount will change the outcome, absent highly credible evidence of error or fraud, meaning the recount serves no genuine purpose except to raise doubt about the election.
Methodology
Definition of “recount”
When performing a recount of election results, ballots are retabulated to confirm the original tally identified the correct winner. Depending on the state, a recount could be performed with different methods, such as electronic review of voting machines or physically counting ballots by hand. Recounts often occur because of a close victory margin, concerns of election fraud, or worry over administrative error when initially processing ballots. For our study, we define an election recount as the process of tabulating the ballots in each precinct in a statewide election a second time.
Definition of “statewide election”
Our study only includes statewide general elections. These elections provide an opportunity for all voters, no matter where they live in the state, to vote for the same candidates or on the same ballot question. A majority of these elections occur in November, while others can take place earlier in the year, such as a special general election or when a ballot question is up for a vote during primary elections. We do not include primary elections because those precede general elections, winners need to win a general election to take office, and primary elections often do not permit every voter to participate. We also do not include most elections for the U.S. House of Representatives because candidates run in districts, and only voters who live in those districts can vote for the respective candidates. However, we include House elections in the states with only a single House district, meaning all voters in the state may participate.
Definition of “victory margin”
The victory margin between the top two candidates was recorded, as well as the size and direction of any shifts in votes. The victory margin is the vote difference between the top two candidates divided by the total number of votes cast for those two candidates.
Data collection
We gathered data on statewide general elections between 2000 and 2025 by visiting secretary of state and Election Board websites. Contact was also made by phone or email with 46 out of 50 state offices. For states with unresponsive offices, data was collected through Lexis-Nexis and Westlaw from Thomson Reuters. Additionally, Ballotpedia and reports from local media channels were utilized for any data collection not available on state websites.
A contest that elected more than one seat was counted as one statewide election because only one recount was needed to confirm the results.
For elections that had recounts, we collected vote totals for only the top two candidates. Therefore, the vote totals included in the report are a combination of votes for only the top two finishers in a given race.
Our full dataset of statewide elections and recounts is available here.
Previous versions of FairVote’s election recounts report included analysis of recounts in presidential elections, and how they might be affected by the National Popular Vote plan for presidential elections. Please review our 2024 recounts report for the latest analysis of recounts and the National Popular Vote.
About the authors
Deb Otis is the Senior Director of Research and Policy at FairVote, focused on the data-driven case for how election reforms work in practice. Deb has been featured on NPR’s All Things Considered, NPR’s On Point, The Downballot, The Preamble with Sharon McMahon, and The Politics Guys. Her work has also appeared in The New York Times, The Washington Post, The Guardian, and more.
Ben Williams is a nonpartisan election policy expert serving as FairVote’s Senior Policy Counsel and Researcher. He leads FairVote’s work on election administration and state legislative policy. Ben has also appeared on C-SPAN’s Washington Journal, and his work has been published in Slate, The Virginian-Pilot, NCSL Magazine, and NCSL’s State Legislatures News.
Appendix: List of statewide recounts, 2000-2025
| State | Year | Office / initiative | Requested or automatic | Recount result | Original % margin for winner | Recount % margin for winner |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Virginia | 2013 | Attorney general | Requested | Upheld | 0.01% | 0.04% |
| North Carolina | 2020 | State Supreme Court | Automatic | Upheld | 0.01% | 0.01% |
| Arizona | 2010 | Proposition 112 | Automatic | Upheld | 0.01% | 0.01% |
| Minnesota | 2008 | U.S. Senate | Automatic | Overturned | 0.01% | -0.01% |
| Washington | 2004 | Governor | Automatic | Overturned | 0.01% | 0.00% |
| North Carolina | 2024 | State Supreme Court | Requested | Upheld | 0.01% | 0.01% |
| Virginia | 2005 | Attorney general | Requested | Upheld | 0.02% | 0.02% |
| Arizona | 2022 | Attorney general | Automatic | Upheld | 0.02% | 0.01% |
| Florida | 2000 | President | Automatic | Upheld | 0.03% | 0.01% |
| Oregon | 2014 | Ballot measure 92 | Automatic | Upheld | 0.05% | 0.06% |
| Oregon | 2008 | Ballot measure 53 | Automatic | Upheld | 0.06% | 0.07% |
| Vermont | 2006 | Auditor of accounts | Requested | Overturned | 0.06% | -0.05% |
| Florida | 2018 | Agriculture commissioner | Automatic | Upheld | 0.07% | 0.08% |
| Colorado | 2000 | State Education Board | Automatic | Upheld | 0.08% | 0.01% |
| Washington | 2000 | U.S. Senate | Automatic | Upheld | 0.08% | 0.09% |
| Georgia | 2004 | Court of Appeals | Automatic | Upheld | 0.08% | 0.09% |
| Montana | 2000 | Superintendent of public instruction | Requested | Upheld | 0.10% | 0.10% |
| New Mexico | 2014 | Public land commissioner | Automatic | Upheld | 0.13% | 0.14% |
| Alabama | 2004 | Constitutional amendment 2 | Automatic | Upheld | 0.13% | 0.13% |
| Florida | 2018 | U.S. Senate | Automatic | Upheld | 0.15% | 0.12% |
| Missouri | 2014 | Constitutional amendment 1 | Requested | Upheld | 0.21% | 0.24% |
| North Carolina | 2014 | State Supreme Court | Requested | Upheld | 0.22% | 0.22% |
| North Carolina | 2006 | Court of Appeals | Requested | Upheld | 0.22% | 0.22% |
| Georgia | 2020 | President | Requested | Upheld | 0.26% | 0.25% |
| Alabama | 2006 | Constitutional amendment 105 | Automatic | Upheld | 0.32% | 0.39% |
| Arizona | 2022 | Superintendent of public instruction | Automatic | Upheld | 0.36% | 0.37% |
| Florida | 2018 | Governor | Automatic | Upheld | 0.41% | 0.40% |
| Minnesota | 2010 | Governor | Automatic | Upheld | 0.48% | 0.48% |
| Wisconsin | 2011 | State Supreme Court | Requested | Upheld | 0.49% | 0.47% |
| Washington | 2000 | Secretary of state | Automatic | Upheld | 0.49% | 0.48% |
| North Carolina | 2010 | Court of Appeals | Requested | Upheld | 0.55% | 0.62% |
| Pennsylvania | 2021 | Commonwealth Court | Automatic | Upheld | 0.66% | 0.87% |
| Wisconsin | 2016 | President | Requested | Upheld | 0.80% | 0.82% |
| Alaska | 2004 | U.S. Senate | Requested | Upheld | 3.31% | 3.22% |
| Pennsylvania | 2009 | Superior Court | Requested | Upheld | 4.59% | 4.60% |
| Wyoming | 2004 | Amendment C | Automatic | Upheld | 5.97% | 5.98% |
| Wyoming | 2004 | Amendment A | Automatic | Upheld | 11.55% | 11.55% |
