“Fewest Votes Wins”: 70 Statewide and Congressional Primaries Won With Less Than 50% of the Vote
28 million Americans live in states or districts where a non-majority nominee is almost guaranteed to win election
September 23, 2024 – A new FairVote report finds that 70 major-party candidates won 2024 congressional and statewide primaries with less than 50% of the vote. In our current single-choice voting system, a candidate can win an election with far less than 50% of the vote, meaning a majority of voters voted for someone other than the winner. Ranked choice voting would ensure candidates win with a majority, and send them into the general election with a stronger mandate from their party.
“In states and districts across the country, majority rule has been replaced with ‘fewest votes wins.’ 28 million Americans live in areas so safe for one party that their elected officials are chosen in the spring and summer by a fraction of a fraction of the electorate,” said Deb Otis, Director of Research and Policy at FairVote. “With ranked choice voting, voters get real choices, parties get stronger nominees, and candidates need a majority to win. It’s a win-win solution, and that’s why it’s become the fastest-growing voting reform in the nation.”
Non-majority primary winners present two major problems for our elections:
- If the candidate is in a district safe for their party, they’ve essentially secured an office with just a fraction of a fraction of their constituents behind them. 33 of this year’s non-majority winners won the dominant party’s primary (i.e. a Republican primary in a red district, or a Democratic primary in a blue district) and are all but guaranteed to win their general elections. 28 million people live in these safe states or districts, and will be represented by someone who has effectively been elected by a sliver of voters. Examples include the Republican nominees for governor of Missouri and Indiana, and the Democratic nominee for governor of Delaware.
- If the candidate is in a competitive district, they enter the general election weaker, without most of their party behind them. Recent research from Northwestern University and FairVote finds that plurality primary winners are 11.3 percentage points less likely to win competitive general elections than candidates who win the primary with a majority. 17 of this year’s non-majority winners are moving on to a competitive election – raising questions about whether the party has put its best foot forward in these races. Examples of plurality primary winners who fared poorly in 2022 included Mehmet Oz and Doug Mastriano in Pennsylvania, Don Bolduc and Karoline Leavitt in New Hampshire, and most of the Arizona statewide Republican ticket (including Blake Masters, Kari Lake, Abe Hamadeh, and Mark Finchem).
Additional key findings in the report include:
- In 27 U.S. House races with partisan primaries, an incumbent chose to retire rather than seek re-election. In 17 (62%) of those seats, the incumbent party’s nominee did not earn a majority of the primary vote. Retiring House members are being replaced with candidates who failed to appeal to a majority of their party’s primary voters, which may contribute to more polarized politics. (Notably, six of the eight GOP representatives who ejected Kevin McCarthy from the Speakership last year won their first primaries with a plurality.)
- 17 of this year’s non-majority winners won with a third of the vote or less.
Ranked choice voting is the fastest-growing voting reform in the nation; it has now grown to 50 states, counties, and cities home to approximately 16 million Americans across the nation. In primaries, it would ensure that nominees have broad support from voters and send nominees into the general election in a stronger position to win.
RCV has won 27 city ballot measures in a row; this November, it will be on the ballot for statewide adoption in four states plus the District of Columbia.
The list of all 70 candidates who won 2022 primaries with less than 50% of the vote is available here.
###
FairVote is a nonpartisan organization seeking better elections for all. We research and advance voting reforms that make democracy more functional and representative for every American.
