Could ranked choice voting prevent the next government shutdown?
On Saturday, Congress passed legislation to fund the government for 45 days, kicking the immediate threat of a government shutdown down the road.
But it might not even be that long before Congress falls back into chaos. Florida Rep. Matt Gaetz plans to put a “motion to vacate” (a vote to remove Kevin McCarthy as Speaker) on the floor as early as this week. This could kick off a saga of votes to elect a new Speaker similar to the 15-round marathon Americans saw in January.
In an op-ed published on MSNBC, Democratic Reps. Jamie Raskin (MD-08) and Don Beyer (VA-08) offer their explanation for how we got here, and chart a path out of the morass using ranked choice voting:
Working with a thin four-vote majority after House Republicans underperformed in the 2022 midterms, McCarthy paid the political ransom demanded by these ‘rule-or-ruin’ holdouts in the GOP Conference to win a majority of the vote [for Speaker]…
There is a far better way to choose the speaker (and other key House leaders) than a series of simple majority ballots that can easily lead to capitulation to extremists. The alternative is ranked choice voting, which enables an instant runoff and certifies the winner who has the widest and deepest support.
They continue:
Ranked choice voting incentivizes leaders to govern responsibly and makes our elections more democratic. It would help ensure that future speakers — regardless of party — are structurally accountable to the mainstream majority, instead of the extortionist few.
Lastly, Reps. Raskin and Beyer perfectly identify what happens when a fraction of a fraction of voters elect members of Congress in hyper-partisan districts:
Most of the 20 members who shook down McCarthy and caused the chaos in January represent some of the most skewed and lopsided districts in the nation. Almost all of them owe their seats to some combination of partisan redistricting and low-turnout primary elections that place extreme fringe candidates in uncompetitive general elections they can’t lose. This undemocratic process creates the gridlock that is keeping us from funding our government and is threatening public services and the livelihood of our federal employees. Ranked choice voting would go a long way toward fixing the problem.
Read the full op-ed on MSNBC.
